Replacing a toilet is usually a one- to two-hour job for a licensed plumber. The right choice depends on your bathroom, how you use it, and whether the flange, shut-off valve and floor underneath are in good shape. Standard two-piece, comfort-height, one-piece, dual-flush, smart and wall-hung toilets each have pros and cons, and a new WaterSense toilet can cut your water use significantly.
We’ve been installing toilets in Tampa Bay homes since 1976. Here are your toilet options, what a replacement includes, the hidden problems to watch for, and how to decide whether to repair or replace.
Need help now? Our licensed technicians serve all of Tampa Bay, 24/7.
Toilet types to choose from
| Toilet type | Good to know |
|---|---|
| Standard two-piece | The most common choice and easiest to service |
| Comfort-height (ADA height) | About 2 to 3 inches taller, easier on knees and backs |
| One-piece | Sleek and easier to clean, with no tank-to-bowl seam |
| Dual-flush | Light flush for liquids, full flush for solids |
| Smart or bidet toilet | May need a new GFCI outlet installed by an electrician |
| Wall-hung | Requires a carrier frame inside the wall, usually during a remodel |
What’s included in a toilet replacement
- Shutting off the water and removing the old toilet
- Inspecting the flange and floor for damage
- Installing the new toilet with a new wax ring and closet bolts
- A new supply line, and leveling and sealing the base
- Testing for leaks and checking the flush
- Hauling away the old toilet
Most toilet replacements take one to two hours.
Hidden problems to watch for
| Problem | Why it comes up |
|---|---|
| Flange repair or replacement | A cracked or corroded flange causes leaks and wobbling |
| New shut-off valve | Older valves often seize or leak when turned |
| Subfloor repair | Years of slow leaks can rot the wood under the toilet |
| Drain line clearing | If the old toilet was clogging because of the line, not the toilet |
| Electrical outlet for a smart toilet | Bidet and smart toilets need power near the toilet |
Most Tampa homes are built on concrete slabs, so subfloor rot is less common here than in homes with wood floors. Second-story bathrooms and older raised homes are the exception.

Repair or replace your toilet?
Repair it if:
- It runs constantly or refills on its own. A new flapper or fill valve usually fixes it. See our guide on why a toilet keeps running.
- It leaks at the base. A new wax ring may solve it.
- The handle or flush mechanism is broken.
Replace it if:
- The tank or bowl is cracked, even a hairline crack.
- It clogs constantly with normal use.
- It was installed before 1994. Older toilets use 3.5 gallons or more per flush, compared with 1.28 gallons for today’s WaterSense models.
- You’ve paid for several repairs in the past couple of years.
- It wobbles even after the bolts are tightened, which can mean a damaged flange or floor.
Our guide on how long a toilet lasts has more on lifespan.
How a new toilet can lower your water bill
Toilets are one of the biggest water users in most homes. Replacing a pre-1994 toilet with a 1.28-gallon WaterSense model can save a family thousands of gallons a year. It also helps if your Tampa water bill is too high. Check with your water utility for any current toilet rebate programs.
Tips for choosing a toilet in Tampa
- Measure the rough-in. Measure from the wall to the center of the bolts at the base. Most homes are 12 inches, but some are 10 or 14.
- Look for a high MaP flush rating. MaP scores show how much waste a toilet clears in one flush. Higher is better.
- Pick an elongated or round bowl based on bathroom space. Elongated is more comfortable but needs about 2 more inches.
- Think about hard water. Tampa’s water is hard, and mineral buildup can slow flushes over time. Glazed trapways and simple fill valves are easier to keep clean.
- Consider a tankless model for a modern look. Read how tankless toilets work.
Frequently asked questions
What affects the price of a toilet replacement?
The toilet you choose, the condition of the flange, shut-off valve and floor, and whether the toilet is being moved or the drain changed. We give you a written price before any work starts.
How long does it take to replace a toilet?
Usually one to two hours. Flange or floor repairs can add time.
How often should a toilet be replaced?
The porcelain can last decades, but the parts wear out. Most homeowners replace toilets every 15 to 25 years, or sooner if they crack, clog often or use a lot of water.
Is it worth replacing an old toilet?
Yes, if it’s from before 1994, cracked or needs frequent repairs. New WaterSense toilets use 1.28 gallons per flush or less and lower your water bill.
Do I need a permit to replace a toilet in Tampa?
A like-for-like toilet replacement usually doesn’t need a permit. Moving the toilet or changing drain lines does. Your plumber should know your local requirements.
Can I replace a toilet myself?
Many handy homeowners can. The most common DIY problems are uneven wax ring seals, cracked tanks from overtightened bolts, and leaks from reused supply lines. Those leaks can damage floors before you notice them.
Why Tampa homeowners choose Alvarez for toilet replacement
- 50 years in Tampa Bay. We’re a family-owned company that has served Tampa Bay homes since 1976.
- Thousands of 5-star reviews. We’re rated 4.8 stars from more than 2,700 Google reviews and are BBB A+ accredited.
- No subcontractors. Every job is done by our own trained, licensed technicians, so the people who quote your job are accountable for the work.
- We guarantee our work. We stand behind every job we do. If something isn’t right, we come back and make it right.
Get your toilet replaced
We’ll give you a written price up front, including the toilet, installation and haul-away. Call (813) 655-7520 or request service online. Learn more about our toilet repair and replacement service.
Book online in under a minute, or call and talk to a real person.